27 GERKOR Quiniou

 


Germany escaped this game with victory, clinging onto a three-two win, having scored thrice in the opening half-an-hour. Korea did themselves proud, and offered a premonition to future successes. Joël Quiniou handled his second game of the tournament, and as in the first, did a good job.

French referee did not need to intervene very much in a football-focused match, and the key to success was setting tactically clever signals with his cautions and keeping up with this game. He managed both and realised a strong expected level performance. Some other small pointers:

=> The holding foul at 15' was a very clear yellow card, and a mistake not to open the sanctions there. 

=> I wouldn't have minded a red card being issued for a lunging tackle at 11'! Freekick only was also an understandable choice.

=> With Jürgen Klinsmann having already been cautioned for playing after the whistle, should he have been booked again for a similar offence in the second half? Besides self-preservation, in my view no - his act was much more minor this time.

=> Despite large Korea appeals, I simply cannot see a clear handling offence at 82'. 


Quite a challenging game for Valentin Ivanov who realised a very good performance, but made an important mistake at 69'. Abdulmajid Hassan also made one mistake, controlling the less challenging half. 

Joël Quiniou - 8,4
Valentin Ivanov - 8,3
Abdulmajid Hassan - 8,3
Arturo Angeles

FRA, RUS, EGY
Germany 3-2 Korea Republic

Group Stage
Gelbe Karten 
Brehme (24') - Tackle
Klinsmann (28') - Delaying the Restart
Effenberg (45') - Tackle
Gelbe Karten 
Choi Young-il (89') - SPA (Tripping)

Comments

  1. Quiniou had a decent game and remained in control despite not being as colourful and involved as other referees. What irked me a bit was the lack of SPA prevention over large parts of the game, I'm quite sure 2-3 cards were absolutely mandatory here. Penalty appeal is unclear.

    More interesting: Sending Klinsmann off for his second DtR offence or for him lashing out in the first half (either RC or SYC) was entirely possible and might have changed the outcome.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts